Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Martha's Mother

1910
Charlotte Perkins Gilman
Martha's Mother
B-

Martha's mom comes to town to run a boarding-house for Martha and other hard-working single gals.  Again, we're given a how-to, but most of us won't have country connections who can send us cheap produce.  Still, the talk about how much things cost and other details are fun.  The story ends with Martha's mother sending away Martha's sexually harassing boss.  (Presumably, Martha doesn't lose her job.)

When I Was a Witch

1910
Charlotte Perkins Gilman
When I Was a Witch
B-

A New York woman tells of how she's granted the power to make some of her wishes come true, wishes to reform society, like stopping animal abuse and curbing the dishonest sensational press.  When she wishes "white" magic, wanting women to be freed to mother the world, she loses her power.  All of her other wishes are undone, which is why nowadays you still might see a dog wearing clothes and a bracelet, although not necessarily a pocket-handkerchief.

Her Housekeeper

1910
Charlotte Perkins Gilman
Her Housekeeper
B-

The title character courts a widowed young actress, but this house is being kept (both owned and operated) by a real-estate man.  She has no desire to marry again, and lists the reasons why.  He has a rebuttal to all of them and wins her over, partly by winning over her small son.  (I like the detail of "making country" with clay and bits of looking-glass.)  Points for the discreet reference to orgasm in the last line:  " 'I never had any idea,' she ventured after a while, 'that it could be-- like this.' "  (OK, they may just be kissing, but there is a skipped line after they talk about kissing.)  In any case, they're the first believably happy couple in this Gilman collection.

Howards End

1910, 1992 Signet edition
E. M. Forster
Howards End
Bought new for $4.50
Tattered paperback
B

This edition has movie tie-in front and back covers.  I remember attempting to watch a Merchant Ivory version of E.M. Forster, but I couldn't tell you if it was A Room with a View or Howards End.  I might've even tried both.  All I remember is being bored despite the excellent cast and shutting off the TV after about 15 minutes.  Perhaps I was unjust, but I don't remember Merchant Ivory capturing Forster's wit and complexity.


This novel is very funny, although as Benjamin DeMott points out in the introduction, it's a painful humour.  Helen Schlegel can joke about stealing umbrellas because she's too well off to worry about it, yet everything she says cuts into Leonard Bast.  While in the world of The Automobile Girls, anarchists' resentment of the class system is madness, and a talented Gypsy girl can become civilized, Forster shows that there are no easy solutions, or even clear questions, for the current economic situation.  The Wilcoxes, particularly Charles, think that money solves everything, even the deaths of a cat and a man, but money also creates problems, the possession of it in a different way than its lack.  The title "character" is a house that's owned by possessive people who don't want it to go to people who would appreciate it more than they do.


The Wilcoxes are unlikable, probably more than Forster intended, but I think the Schlegels are meant to be seen, by the reader as well as the other characters, as impractical dreamers.  Looking back over a century later, in which both sides have won and lost-- money is still king but liberalism has made a difference; the "lower classes" have access to education but nobody on the Internet can spell-- all I know is I can't forgive Charles, and Margaret Schlegel is the most reasonable person around.  As for the Basts, it's hard to buy Jacky as Leonard's wife, harder to believe she was Henry Wilcox's "mistress."  A one-night stand, maybe.  I can sort of see Leonard and Helen's one-night stand, although their thread wasn't developed enough and his tragic ending a bit contrived.


For a "modern" book, it's very fatalistic.  At the tail end of the Edwardian period, things still feel very Victorian, but with motorcars.  My favorite character, the first Mrs. Wilcox, is deliberately anachronistic, a relic of a genteeler, more rural time.  Aunt Juley is like Charlotte Bartlett in Room with a View, an interfering older relative, and so it was startling to realize that she's a "Mrs." and not an old maid.  And yet, there is a sense of what lies around the corner, with a line about "the remark, 'England and Germany are bound to fight,' renders war a little more likely each time that it is made, and is therefore made the more readily by the gutter press of either nation."

The Automobile Girls Along the Hudson

1910, undated 1920s Henry Altemus edition
Laura Dent Crane
Illustrated by unknown
The Automobile Girls Along the Hudson, or Fighting Fire in Sleepy Hollow
Original price probably $1.00, purchase price $4.50
Hardcover with broken spine and worn corners 
C+

This is definitely a period piece, from its title to its characters, ranging from Gypsies to a Civil War major.  Crane hits every stereotype about Gypsies, including their dislike of bathing and school, and their fondness for fortune-telling and theft.  To her credit, most of these stereotypes are voiced by cranky Aunt Sallie, and to some degree disproved.  However, one of the Gypsies tries to kill his half-brother, and there are Spanish stereotypes there.  As for the major, by my math he'd have to be about 70, although he comes across as younger.


This story was third in a series of six, and includes plugs for the first two stories on p. 9 and for the fourth on the last page.  The most interesting thing about the book is the advertising of series, including this one, in the back.  Some of the series are about school but others are about young people fighting "the Huns" in the recent Great War.  In the case of Grace Harlowe, you can follow her from her plebe (freshman) year of high school to college, and then overseas to "aid the American fighting forces," before finally "returning from service in France" to work as an Overland Rider in state parks.  There's also a what-if "Conquest of the United States" series, At the Defense of Pittsburgh being one title. 

Besides all the pro-war propaganda, there's some pro-business propaganda.  "Do you know, for instance, that from $10,000 to $12,000 a year is very common pay for the foremen of the great wheat ranches in Kansas?"  The blurb for "The Boys of Steel" series tells us that "The steel industry today offers a splendid field for the efforts of really bright American youths."  And Automobile Girls Along the Hudson shows how insane and violent anarchists are.


Suffragettes come off  better, the subject of harmless jokes.  This series, and other series from this publisher, do feature intelligent, brave, independent girls, like Bab (short for Barbara), the unofficial heroine of this book.  I have to admit that I can't figure out the point of the character Grace.  Maybe she's featured more in other adventures, but I could barely distinguish her from Bab's sister Mollie.  Yes, half a century after An Old-Fashioned Girl, names that end with "ie" are still popular.  There's even a boy named "Jimmie."


Besides the boys' and girls' series, Altemus offers "wee books for wee folks."  Many of these have laugh-out-loud titles, among my favorites:  Grunty Grunts and Smiley Smile--Indoors; Grunty Grunts and Smiley Smile--Outdoors; I Don't Want to Wear Coats and Things; The Mud Wumps of the Sunshine and Shadow Forest; Peter Rabbit, Jack-the-Jumper and the Tinybits; and the entire "Little Bunnie Bunniekin" series, whose titles are all along those lines, like Little Squirrelie Squirreliekin, until you get to Old Red Reynard the Fox.

Due to condition, I won't be keeping this book, but the text is online.  And so is Little Bunnie Bunniekin.

Sunday, March 18, 2012

The Emerald City of Oz

1910, undated Reilly & Lee edition
L. Frank Baum
Illustrated by John R. Neill
The Emerald City of Oz
Original and purchase price unknown
Hardcover with stains
B

Baum intended this to be the last Oz story.  He wanted to write other books, and since he couldn't toss all the characters into Reichenbach Falls, or a well, he decided to have Glinda make the entire country invisible to outsiders.  It didn't work, for him or Glinda, but that's why there are illustrations of the Scarecrow and the Tin Woodman crying.  And that's why the last chapter is called "How the Story of Oz Came to an End."

Not only isn't this the last Oz book, but it's the first Oz book to have creative chapter titles, in this case all starting with the word "how."  It also has a dual storyline, one thread being about how Dorothy, her aunt, and her uncle move to Oz and travel around to odd little towns and villages, the other being about how the Nome King and his general plot to conquer Oz.  Not all that much of the story is set in the Emerald City, although it is the first book since Land to be set mostly in Oz.  It's also an improvement on the previous two Oz books.  We see how charming Oz is and what a loss it would be if the Nomes and their allies laid it to waste.

Chapter Three begins with a description of the Emerald City, including population (57,318 people in 9654 buildings).  Then we're told of the surrounding countryside, and that there are more than half a million people in the Land of Oz, "although some of them, as you will soon learn, were not made of flesh and blood as we are." 

What follows is Baum's first explicitly utopian description of Oz.  Death is rare and poverty unknown.  "All property of every sort belonged to the Ruler," i.e. Ozma.  "The people were her children, and she cared for them."  Everyone shares what they make, whether grain or jewellery.  People work half the time and play half the time.  So basically, this is utopian socialism with a monarchist twist, which I found very appealing as a child and even into my 20s, although now much less so.  Baum says, "I do not suppose such an arrangement would be practical with us," but I wonder if this is one reason the Oz books took so long to be accepted in public libraries.  (The official reason was that librarians didn't want to collect series, an unfathomable thought these days.)

Baum claims that there are no evil Ozites, or even ones "who possess a selfish or violent nature."  Then he admits that there are exceptions, in the remote parts of the land.  "I suppose every country has some drawbacks, so even this almost perfect fairyland could not be quite perfect."  It would be a pretty boring series if it were.

This is the book where Dorothy goes Bunburying, in a more innocent way than Algernon Moncrieff.  She visits a town called Bunbury, entirely composed of baked goods.  Here, and in Utensia, a town entirely composed of utensils and other kitchen aids, Baum lets loose with the puns in a way he probably hasn't since Mo.  Most of them are still accessible, although I think it's been many decades since a masher meant "a man who makes unwelcome sexual advances, often in public places and typically to women he does not know."  He winks at Dorothy "somewhat impertinently" and says, "I'm fond of little girls myself."  Um, yeah.

She also travels to Bunnybury, where she teaches the king to appreciate what he's got, and to towns populated by paper dolls and jigsaw puzzles.  There are also two places, Flutterbudget Center and Rigmarole Town, which are "the Defensive Settlements of Oz," since they house, respectively, people who worry too much and people who talk too much.  Additionally, although not strictly speaking a town, they also visit the Athletic College, where the students acquire knowledge through pills, so they have more time to devote to sports.  All of these places are more interesting than anywhere Dorothy went in the fourth or fifth books.

As for the other main plot, the very first chapter is "How the Nome King Became Angry."  Roquat is upset because he's thinking about how Ozma, Dorothy, and the rest stole his "slaves" (the Evian royal family) and his Magic Belt.  He wants revenge, but his sarcastic servant Kaliko (another of my favorite minor characters) reminds him that he can't cross the deadly desert surrounding Oz.  His new general, Guph, suggests a tunnel, which makes sense since the Nomes are miners.  Guph gets the Whimsies, Growleywogs, and Phanfasms to help, although everyone is planning to sell the others out, including Guph.

Despite going to the rescue of the Evian royals three books ago, Ozma now won't even defend her own country, because war is bad.  Yes, even a war of defense.  She's suddenly become an extreme pacifist.  Of course, she and the other Oz natives probably won't die, but Dorothy and the other immigrants could.  At the least, everyone is going to be enslaved and the country turned into a desert.

Luckily, the Scarecrow, "probably the wisest man in all Oz," comes up with a plan.  He has Ozma use the Magic Belt to fill the tunnel with dust, so that when the warriors emerge, they'll have to slake their thirst in the Forbidden Fountain, whose Water of Oblivion will wipe clean their memories.  This is a fountain that Dorothy has seen on every visit but never mentioned to us before.  It will return, as will the Nome King, but more about that later.

Glinda, who has a Magic Record Book that records all events in the world, knows all that's going on, so she comes up with the invisibility plan.  She doesn't do anything to prevent the invasion, but maybe she trusts the Scarecrow to save them.  For some reason, her castle is now located in the north, but I think this is the beginning of the geographical confusion that plagues the series.  Baum apparently misread a map slide from his traveling show, tried to fix things, and it all got very muddled.  Usually it's east and west that are mixed up, not only with each other but with left and right, and with Munchkin and Winkie.  This also affects the lands outside Oz, so that the Nome Country was closest to the Munchkins in Ozma but is now closest to the Winkies.

Speaking of travel, there's not much point to the Shaggy Man being on the expedition (or Omby Amby for that matter), but he does get the funny line, "I've been to Mexico and Boston and many other foreign countries."  The Wizard chimes in that he's "been to Europe and Ireland."

Dorothy is also accompanied by Billina and Toto, who fought in the previous book but now have made peace.  Billina supposedly is the first chicken in Oz, which doesn't explain how she's managed to have a dozen chicks, all named either Dorothy or Daniel.  Her brood first appeared in Road, but they're already grown up at the beginning of this story, with 86 children and over 300 grandchildren.  In fact, there are two Emerald City chickens in Wizard, and there's an illustration of a Gillikin rooster in Land.  Since no one's allowed to eat or even kill chickens in Oz, their fate is a mystery.

The illustrations are good, with Neill representing nearly every type of the many creatures mentioned.  (There's no view of the Fuddles, but I remember seeing them in a reproduction of a color plate from the first edition.)  There are no particular standouts, although I like the stately columns of the college.

It would be three years before Baum returned to Oz, shorter than the interval between the first and second books, but it wasn't yet a series then.  Meanwhile, he wrote a couple books about Trot and Cap'n Bill, which I've read but don't own.  The Sea Fairies and Sky Island are still in print, although I'm not sure if they contain the Neill illustrations.

Saturday, March 17, 2012

Anne of Avonlea

1909, 1988 Bantam Classic edition
L. M. Montgomery
Anne of Avonlea
Original price $2.95, purchase price $1.75
OK condition paperback
B

The second "Anne" book is just as good as the first.  It covers the two years in which Anne teaches at her old school, and learns a few things herself.  The school parts are fine, but I prefer to read about the AVIS campaign to beautify Avonlea and Miss Lavendar's middle-aged romance.  Anne is 16 to 18 in this story, so she's more grown-up but still getting into scrapes.  She helps Marilla raise twins that a distant relative has left, bratty Davy and boring Dora.  I could've done without this thread, but I guess Montgomery felt that there wasn't enough of children saying the darnedest things.  Fourteen-year-old Charlotta the Fourth is my favorite new character, but I don't think she comes back.  The Mr. and Mrs. Harrison thread is pretty good, although I was surprised that Ginger the parrot is killed off so soon.  There are more references to Canadian politics than usual, and confusingly Mrs. Lynde, who doesn't believe in higher education for women, is a Liberal.

The book ends with Miss Lavendar's wedding, as Anne and Gilbert prepare to go off to Redmond College.  He's been carrying a torch for her for years, but she only gets a sense of it now.  Despite her romantic imagination, she doesn't seem to see what's right in front of her.  She's quicker to spot Diana & Fred.  I don't remember Fred in the first book, but suddenly he's there as part of the gang.  Anne's sad to lose her best friend to marriage, but at least it'll be a long engagement.  Not only does Mrs. Barry want Diana wait till she's 21, but the third Anne book must wait till 1915....